Hiring Your First Head Of Sales

By far, the most frequent question I get from founders is this: How do I go about hiring a Head of Sales? I've literally received this question four times in the last six or seven weeks.

Hiring a Head of Sales at a startup is a very difficult, important, and scary thing for a founder. Making a mistake on this hire can set the company back several quarters. I try to avoid making declarative statements to founders because context is so important and each situation is unique. That said, here are a few things that will help reduce the risk associated with hiring a Head of Sales for the first time:

1/ Ensure the candidate has been an ultra-successful individual contributor. I know, I know, the best salespeople aren’t necessarily the best managers. You don't need the best salesperson in the world, but you do need someone who has done it before. In startup sales, you can't lead the calvary if you can't sit in the saddle. Strong sales capabilities (both to sell direct and to sell salespeople on joining the company) are crucial in this role. If this candidate can't sell, they likely can't recruit. It’s not worth that risk.

2/ Ensure the candidate has sold into (roughly) similar-sized organizations in the past. If you're selling to large enterprises, don't hire an SMB expert, and vice-versa. It's not impossible to make the transition, but it's relatively unlikely that it will be successful. Often, the things that make people good at SMB sales make them bad at enterprise sales. Also, do consider the candidate's experience with the vertical you're selling into. Ideally, you will be able to find someone who has sold into that vertical in the past. I wouldn't make this a requirement in every situation. The importance of this is industry dependent. But if the industry has a steep learning curve, optimize around that set of experience.

3/ If you have the capital, hire a headhunter to help. Doing this search right requires an expertise and time investment that most founders can't afford. This is a good opportunity to outsource.

4/ Hire a “stretch VP.” A stretch VP is a rising star (generally Director level) that needs to level-up a bit to become a sales leader at a larger organization. This type of candidate will generally lean towards execution but will have the potential to recruit and run a team. This is a good hedge. If the candidate levels-up and can run the whole sales organization, that's great. If they can't, it'll be easier to “level” them with a more senior candidate. If you hire someone too senior, you run the risk that they won't be execution-focused, and it will be difficult/impossible to level the candidate if things don't work out. A stretch VP is a good way to reduce risk.

5/ Overinvest in intrinsics. This candidate is going to be accepting a very difficult job. Make sure they have the intrinsics that will make them successful in a high-pressure startup environment — grit, humility, adaptability, and curiosity. More on that here. Also, this is hard to do, but make sure the candidate is someone that is at a stage in their life and career they simply aren’t willing to fail. Some call this “personal exceptionalism” — more on that here.